update: I found the song! It's Fathers and Daughters by Michael Bolton. The line is actually "That's not how the story goes." It's crazy: It's in a youtube video that I like and have seen multiple times, and I happened to watch it today, only 1 day after I had the song stuck in my head.more »
Helllp. I just got the song stuck in my head and the only line I remember is "This isn't how our story goes." I'm pretty sure that's right. I can hum a few other lines but can't remember other words.more »